Shooters Forum banner

45 colt load

13605 Views 43 Replies 22 Participants Last post by  Legolas
Ruger Bisley Blackhawk 5.5" barrel. Will be shooting 250 gr XTP bullet. Available powders on hand:H110,Longshot, Titegroup,Lilgun,Universal. Looking for the most accurate load based on your experiences. Would like something in the 1000-1100 fps velocity. Running out of time deer season right around the corner. Out of my typical 255SWC bullets. Only bullet available locally (without ordering) is the XTP. FYI, I have had great results with the 255 SWC Hardcast with 21 grains lilgun. Looking for that mythical "magic load" with the XTP. Please help.
21 - 40 of 44 Posts
Nobody took more then 6 shots with my Ruger and I had to put Pachmeyer grips on the monster. Does not match a .44 mag but kills deer just fine.
What a great old timer that you can do almost anything with. A 335 gr LBT or a 320 gr Lyman with 296 but then a 250 with 7 gr of Unique is pure fun.
I never tried Tite Group and it might be a good idea but a .45 can be a handful.
What's a 4-Sigma? 72gr? Never mind, found them. Never heard of AL bullets that light for a 45ACP/LC. Interesting idea along the lines of wax bullets. No recoil to speak of.
If you really want.to to make that Ruger bark run a published charge of h110. I run the whole enchilada, which I believe is 26.5 hrs., be sure to verify that on Hodgdon' loading site.
Couple things to know . Use a magnum primer, a good stout roll crimp, and absolutely do not reduce the charge to below published minimum with h110 or 296. It's one of those powders that can't be reduced, other wise it can act unpredictably, to include catastrophic over pressures, hang fires, and squibs. Just stick to the published data and you'll be fine.
HBC
I run the whole enchilada, which I believe is 26.5 hrs.,C
Not one to suggest you are doing it wrong Sub, but if running an enchilada takes you 26.5 hrs, you may want to consider driving instead :D:D

Your memory is good, 250gr XTP is 26.5 Grs. from a Ruger, currently on the Hodgy site.
Surprisingly, I guess my memory isn't as bad as I thought Darkker.

SMOA
You might think about trying Unique it is an old powder that works really well in 45 Colts. Yes it is dirty and can be a little Smokey but works great. It has a wide range of power levels that get pretty close to where your looking to be. It works well in medium length barrels like your 5.5 incher. Many old fashion target loads used Unique. Almost every loading manual will show loads with Unique. 8.0 grains is my do everything 45 Colt load for 4 5/8" revolvers to 24 inch rifles. I have competed successfully in several close range steel matches with the 24 inch 45 Colt rifle. Unique will work well in 38 special, 357 Mag, 44 mag. 45 ACP etc. even in lead bullet rifle loads. If I could only have one hand gun powder unique would likely be it.
Yes, good powder for lighter bullets. for the heavy ones, 296 is best and the WW primer for standard or magnum loads seems best and more accurate then a Fed 155 but I use a 150 with 296 in the .45 and .44 mag. Don't load lighter then book with H110 or 296 or it might not light off. I have used the Fed 150 since 1980 or so with great results. Best primer for Unique too.
I have rubber bullets from the Blue Press that just uses a primer and a box of rags in the basement gets you good practice. Need to drill the flash hole some and never use the brass for full loads. Can you go through primers! The rubber bullets can be used over and over, maybe forever. A .45 is never going away. It does everything.
Not one to suggest you are doing it wrong Sub, but if running an enchilada takes you 26.5 hrs, you may want to consider driving instead :D:D

Your memory is good, 250gr XTP is 26.5 Grs. from a Ruger, currently on the Hodgy site.
Linebaugh runs H110 up to 27gr with the data specifically mentioning safe for 250gr XTP with pressure still in 30,6000 range and velocity at 1459fps. Unique he runs max at 12.0gr with about the same pressure and velocity at 1199 fps.

He gives a good rundown of this stuff with maximum 100% safe pressures for the Blackhawks at 32,000 CUP with a measured factory destruction pressure around 60,000 CUP so the loads he is running are safe and 1/2 the destruction level.

I've tried it for fun with a couple of my Blackhawks and I can tell you near the top it's eye opening to say the least. However, although I had no signs of pressure at all i wouldn't care to subject my pistols to those loads on a daily basis, hunting only type stuff imh as the recoil will get your attention. I slipped one near max into one of my long barrel Blackhawks and had my daughter shoot some. I taught her how to ride recoil so when that Linebaugh load went off the gun rolled in her wrist then went way over her head in a picture perfect arc. She looked at me then started laughing wanting more of those. ;)

Be very careful doing this type of stuff if you try it. Linebaugh only recommends Blackhawks, Bisleys and Super Blackhawks. Some say Dan Wesson's are in this category but since Linebaugh specifically says Blackhawks that would be a good indication to stay with them. Always start at book an work up very slowly using a chronograph to show signs of erratic velocities along with visual inspection of the cases and primers. Anything look odd then STOP.

Here is a the site with a good read on the subject https://www.johnlinebaughcustomsixguns.com/writings
See less See more
Wow, you guys are a bunch of lunatics! The .45 Colt is NOT a .44 Mag, even in a Ruger Blackhawk, or a Redhawk.

The average full power .44 Mag is about 35k pressure for a 240 gr. XTP type bullet. The equivalent load in .45 Colt only runs about 28k pressure because the .45 is about 5% larger in diameter. Crank up the pressure to the same 35k and you're asking for trouble.

Remember that the original BP load was a 250 gr. at approx 875-900 fps depending on which factory was loading it and how long the barrel was. That is a very potent load, and is what established the .45 Colt as a man-stopper. That load runs about 14k pressure.

You can pump up the volume as the song goes, so you're at about 20k and you can a significant amount of power increase. A load of 13 gr. of Blue Dot under a 265 gr. WFN falls into that area. That load runs about 1150 in my Blackhawk and will perforate a 100 lb whitetail end to end with no problems at all at 75 yds. Its a pretty stiff load, and not a fun load for plinking. But its also a far, far cry from the loads y'all are talking about with H110, etc.

The Redhawk is about 30% stronger than the Blackhawk, and I would hesitate to run loads above 28-30k even in that. It would NOT be fun by any stretch of the imagination.
See less See more
Freedom Arms told me over the phone, and now IIRC, has the published Plus P 45 Colt load, using their 300 gr. JSP bullets, over IMR 700. It's right at 20KCUP, or Plus P, and is really too much for the old Gen 2 Peacemaker, I was shooting a few in. They clock at around 650fps, out of the 4 & 3/4'rs inch barrels, and there's no expansion. Keeping things down to below 15KCUP, makes a whole lot more sense. Just look between your six shooter's chambers, at those paper thin walls. Want more? Then buy a Ruger Redhawk, in 454 Casull, or 480 Ruger. Last year's discounted price, locally, was a little over $700, plus tax. Curiously, the 454 Redhawk uses an extra slow, 1 in 24 rifling twist, instead of the 45 Colt, one in sixteen's. Do Ya think they're trying to serve, us hand loading's hot rodders??

There are better choices, all the way around! Even some diehards ordered 45 Colt cylinders in Freedom Arms 454 Casull frames, so they could seat their bullets out in properly chambered revolvers, without the extra jump in the longer chambers. The Redhawks finally solved this frame window problem. Per a phone call to F.A. I learned that they won't ever make an intermediate length frame window, for 2.25 inch C.O.A.L. ammo, like the 357 Maximum. You'd need to order a custom BFR for one of these two inch long cartridges.
See less See more
I think the point I was making is that a 45LC can be loaded pretty darn stout if someone wants to in the proper gun. No, it's not a 44Mag, 454Casull etc but with the proper bullet most likely will get whatever you need done, done.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
I think the point I was making is that a 45LC can be loaded pretty darn stout if someone wants to in the proper gun. No, it's not a 44Mag, 454Casull etc but with the proper bullet most likely will get whatever you need done, done.

your right. the 44 mag isn't even a 44 magnum. :eek: it's a .429 magnum and it is inferior to the 45 colt in every way.:p

There is nothing the .429 can do that the 45 colt can't do better.;)
  • Like
Reactions: 1
[2400] is by FAR the most versatile powder for the "magnums" and colt. Paper punching loads, or grizzly thumpers are easily obtained with 2400.
GIGANTO +1

Sorry to be a little late to the party, on this thread, but I FULLY endorse the use of 2400 in heavy-bullet .45 Colt Ruger-T/C only (there simply MUST be a more convenient acronym, somewhere) loads and their work-up. It is probably true that H110/W296 or IMR/H4227 will deliver a slight edge over 2400 in velocities, but I suspect the difference could not easily be detected without a chronograph. It is likely that neither the shooter nor their target would discern much of a difference.

Alliant 2400's behaviour at less-than-"+P" .45 Colt loads is also far less probematical than the Hodgdon/IMR powders I mention. Although I've neither experienced, observed, nor even HEARD of problems with the 4227s when used in loads well below max, treating H110/W296 like that has been an observable invitation to trouble. When the loading manuals recommend load reductions no greater than 3% of max and the use of magnum pistol primers for H110/w296, PLEASE DO take them seriously.

I also think 44GUY offers excellent advice about experimenting with Alliant Unique. You probably won't squeeze the very last micro-joule of muzzle energy available from the cartridge with it, but you'll end up with some very accurate, quite warm, quite capable loads, which should be somewhat less punishing than the max H110 or 4227 reloads. As big a fan as I am of Unique, I tend to think that its close relative Alliant Herco gives slightly better velocities and uniformity in the .45 Colt. I'm still experimenting with Alliant BE-86, which comes across as a slightly cleaner-burning, better-metering UNIQUE, allegedly formulated with flash suppressants. If you simply cannot tolerate the (minimal) disadvantages of flake powders like Unique & Herco, there's nothing much wrong with AA#5, which is in the same approximate burning-rate range as the aforementioned powders. It is probably the slowest-burning of the ones I mention, and works VERY well when pushed hard in .357 Magnum loads.
See less See more
Kosh, that's a very good post. If you shoot the big stuff, 44-45 calibers, then the only two powders you really need are Herco and 2400. There are lots of other good powders around (I've had really good success with Silhouette), but these two oldies will get everything done, from 700-1500 fps, with very good to great accuracy. Herco is a little slower and a little bulkier and a little cleaner burning than Unique, all of which are good by me. It's also usually easier to find where I live, and cheaper too. 2400 is very accurate in all my revolvers, and makes a decent "download" powder for rifles as well.
With regard to the loads suitable only in the Ruger/TC-Contender, the proper term is Tier 3. Tier 1 is Colt SAA originals and clones, Tier 2 is Colt 1909 DA, S&W Triple Locks, and similar, Tier 3 is Ruger Blackhawks, Redhawks, T/C, Freedom SA, etc. Pressures equate to 14k max for Tier 1, 20k for Tier 2, and 28k and above for Tier 3.

As far as powders for high Tier 2, Tier 3 loads, Blue Dot is an excellent choice. It is somewhat slower than Unique, and is in the same class as 2400 but burns a lot cleaner. A very good load for hunting with the .45 Colt is the 265 WFN-GC over 13 gr. Blue Dot sized at .454". Velocity is about 1050-1100 in a 7.5" Blackhawk, with exceptional accuracy.
Thank, Black Mamba. That's kind of you.
I have used Blue Dot in strong midrange loads for .357, and it shot very well (good power with not much recoil). But the little blue marker dots in the powder (perhaps made of nylon or something like that) escaped through the cylinder gap and I could feel them burning on my forearm as I was wearing short sleeves. They might burn little holes in the fabric of a long sleeve shirt. I guess I have too much cylinder gap.
I have used Blue Dot in strong midrange loads for .357, and it shot very well (good power with not much recoil). But the little blue marker dots in the powder (perhaps made of nylon or something like that) escaped through the cylinder gap and I could feel them burning on my forearm as I was wearing short sleeves. They might burn little holes in the fabric of a long sleeve shirt. I guess I have too much cylinder gap.
I'm inclined to call you out on that one. Explain yourself a bit better please.
Have to agree with Cheezywan. Not buying it at all. I've burned over 100 lbs of Blue Dot over the last 40 odd years. If you're getting enough unburned powder to do what you claim, you aren't using that powder correctly. It needs full pressure to work as designed, with medium heavy to heavy bullets. When you do that, you have very little residue.
I'm inclined to call you out on that one. Explain yourself a bit better please.
Sounds like the timing might be a little off. I had a revolver once that would do that and I ended up getting rid of it. The spatters were not really the powder but the shaved lead from the bullet.
21 - 40 of 44 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top