[MikeG]

I like Fobus for Glocks (had a G23 also) as they are rigid and protect the trigger.  No experience with the other brands.

Depends what you are using it for, I suppose, but for the price I was very satisfied with the Fobus.  I mainly used it to keep the pistol handy while hog hunting.  You pretty much forget it's there.

 

[MikeG]

I put the paddle inside the pants also.  Did have to trim off one sharp edge on the Fobus but after that it was very comfortable.