Rob,
Based on experience, I would say the Lee. Of course I have not used the Lyman so I am somewhat biased. In all seriousness, either should do you well. After much use it is now getting a little loose in the ram. If you do want to be able to full-length re-size, the Huntington hand press is worth looking at. Another to consider would be either the RCBS Partner press, or the similar one from Lee, they don't cost much more than the hand tools. The hand presses will full-length size, but the effort is very high. Also, a hand press isn't really good for rifle length cases as the effort to pull over the expander button comes at a point where the mechanical advantage is very low. For small cases, and straight ones like .45-70 or .38-55 which are expanded as a separate operation this isn't a problem.
I have had my Lee for over 25 years and use it mostly for loading in front of the TV. I am not recommending watching TV while loading as it can be a real distraction. Until you have loaded for years and have a set pattern for doing the various steps I would strongly recommend that only non-critical steps, size, expand, prime, be done where such a distraction exists.
A safety hint, since you indicate this is new to you. Powder charging is potentially the most dangerous aspect of re-loading. Buy a loading block, and when you are charging cases do all at the same time. After charging all of your cases, then check the powder level in them before attempting to seat bullets. One of the most problematic ways to load is to charge a case and then immediately seating a bullet. You will be amazed how often a bullet gets seated without powder!!!!
Based on experience, I would say the Lee. Of course I have not used the Lyman so I am somewhat biased. In all seriousness, either should do you well. After much use it is now getting a little loose in the ram. If you do want to be able to full-length re-size, the Huntington hand press is worth looking at. Another to consider would be either the RCBS Partner press, or the similar one from Lee, they don't cost much more than the hand tools. The hand presses will full-length size, but the effort is very high. Also, a hand press isn't really good for rifle length cases as the effort to pull over the expander button comes at a point where the mechanical advantage is very low. For small cases, and straight ones like .45-70 or .38-55 which are expanded as a separate operation this isn't a problem.
I have had my Lee for over 25 years and use it mostly for loading in front of the TV. I am not recommending watching TV while loading as it can be a real distraction. Until you have loaded for years and have a set pattern for doing the various steps I would strongly recommend that only non-critical steps, size, expand, prime, be done where such a distraction exists.
A safety hint, since you indicate this is new to you. Powder charging is potentially the most dangerous aspect of re-loading. Buy a loading block, and when you are charging cases do all at the same time. After charging all of your cases, then check the powder level in them before attempting to seat bullets. One of the most problematic ways to load is to charge a case and then immediately seating a bullet. You will be amazed how often a bullet gets seated without powder!!!!